Odinism is a religion which stands on its own, has its own traditions, and is much older than Christianity. Why, then, when we look at an Odinist teaching, should anyone judge it not by its authenticity, but on whether it is 'too Christian' or 'too Catholic'?
The simple answer is that some people get involved with Odinism, not because they know all about Odinism and agree with it, but because they are ticked off at their own Christian upbringing and feel that being an Odinist is a way to rebel against it.
During our baby-Odinist phase many of us are mad at the Christians. Others are rebelling against Mommy and Daddy. But by the time we get to the point where we want to start expressing opinions on what Odinism is and where it is heading, we ought to be a great deal more grown up than that.
Christianity is actually a variant form of the Jewish faith. Both Christianity and Judaism come from the ancient folk-faith of the Hebrews. If the Hebrew folk-religion is false and bad, what makes us think Odinism, the folk-faith of the Gothic/Germanic/Teutonic folk, is any more true? Either the folk-religions of the world--- Hebrew as well as Odinist--- are true enough to be worth following or they are not.
The ancient Hebraic faith stands side by side with Odinism, Druidism, Religio Romana and all the other folk-faiths. Yes, there are differences in details--- sometimes because one folk-faith is more accurate on a topic than others, sometimes because of a mere cultural difference. But all these folk-faiths, and their universalist children such as Christianity, Islam and Mormonism, have a good deal in common.
Therefore, if you choose at every turn to follow an 'Odinism' which is the opposite of Christianity, or the opposite of Biblical tradition, on every point, you will in a great many cases be doing also the opposite of true historical Odinism as well.
So--- the question is this: what are you really? Are you a follower of historical Odinism, who will follow the teachings as you know them whether they are the same as Christianity or different? Or are you an opposite-of-Christian, in every case doing the opposite of what the Christians teach (and thus allowing the Christians to rule you still)?
You need to think about this issue clearly and take a side. The Odinist/Asatru movement is clogged up with people who call themselves Odinists but are truly just in rebellion against Christianity. Is it any wonder that Odinism has failed to progress? First, because it certainly must displease the Gods when we reject parts of the holy Odinist faith just in order to spite the spiritual children of the Hebrews.
Second, because much of what is being rejected isn't Christianity, but the practical things that help a religion survive. Our ancient Odinist ancestors, for example, had temples such as the one at Upsala, and had a dedicated priesthood who were consecrated to the task, for whom serving the Gods was a life's-work and not a role-playing game. Yet many opposite-of-Christian 'Odinists' not only don't want to have a part in building modern temples themselves, but have conniption fits over other folk doing it.
Now, I'm sure my words are controversial. But if you are truly dedicated to the Gods, and won't let Christianity dictate to you how you will practice our ancient faith, then YOU are an essential part of the future of our faith. Don't let the opposite-of-Christians--- even if they are passing themselves off as Asatru leaders--- rob you of our true ancient faith.
If you agree with the sort of things you read in Nine Virtues News, tell your friends about it. If you have a blog or website you think shares the same views, do use the guestbook in order to tell me about it, and I will put up a link to your site somewhere.